That's a structural break I hate how teraflex acts like they make the strongest products when most of the time they are cheap pos but at least it's not the actual hinge assembly just that cheesy piece that holds tire I might go with the hinge but not buy that pos universal tire mount
To this day, I have yet to see or hear of a single OE tailgate hinge break even if it were holding up a 35" or 37" tire. Why replace something that has proven itself to work and work well?