I'm sure it's a case by case basis for carrier noise. On my 12jks I had 18x9 wheel 4.25" backspacing with 33x12.5/18 Nitto Ridge Grappler mounted in the OEM carrier with 2 spacers. The rattling and chatter coming from it drove me crazy, it was constant. I did the spacer mod that Eddie posted the right up for and although it helped it certainly didn't cure it.