I went with the Pro-Comp 2.5 inch lift from 4 Wheel parts. It was $519 however if you google 4wheelparts coupons there are several codes you can enter. I am happy with the lift. It gave me about 3 inches all the way around and I am running Micky Thompson Baja LTZ 305/65/17 and there. Looks good and rides good. It comes with springs shocks and aft tie rod relocation bracket. I chose this lift because it is what the dealership puts on the JK's they sell and it won't void my warranty and it was She Who Must Be Obeyed (SWMBO) approved.
Happy Trails.