You may not have any problem at all getting that price. You are certainly in the right ballpark. All depends on how motivated the buyers in your area are at the moment. I've seen some sell for less than $1000 and some for over $1500.
Start it at what you really want, or a little above, and see where it goes from there. Best of luck!
I would list it for $1450 and not settle for less than 1300 if its in good shape. They are not cheap when you bought it don't accept less than what it's worth. Like above, it depends on the buyer and how quickly you need to sell it.
Check your market So. Cal JKU hard tops lots on Craigslist now JK two door tops hard to find thus fetching top dollar
Sold mine in one day $1500 no questions asked