I found the Cooper STT Pro in a 37x13.50 to be WAY BETTER then the Trail Grapplers in a 37" size. The 40" Trail Grappler is a totally different tire and on the rocks, they're pretty similar to the STT Pro with the edge having to go to the STT Pro when especially when it comes to hooking up on the rocks. On snow/ice, the STT Pros are also still much better than the Trail Grapplers. Cornering fast in a sandy wash, the Trail Grapplers will do a better job of holding your line.
Thanks for the update.