I sold my hardtop and got the twill trektop about 1.5 years ago. The twill trektop looks so awesome I never plan on putting a hard top back on my jeep. I had the twill full soft top also, the twill trektop is quieter than that, but a little bit louder than a hardtop. The material is just so nice, rich black inside and outside, dirt and mud tend to wash off pretty easy too. The only downside is you lose the functionality of a flip up back window, and fully securing your jeep since the windows can be cut or zipped off. I like the trektop so much though, that I am willing to accept those down sides. Oh, and I have never had a single water leak! Love this top!