What time are you guys hitting the trails? I run the Sedona trails all the time, but I'm located in Phoenix, so it would have to be a noon or later run for me to make it up there and join. Broken Arrow is fun for crawling on the red rocks, but you can almost certainly expect a few skid plate dings if you are running a stock setup. My 3 favorites out that way are Broken Arrow, Soldier's Pass and Greasy Spoon, in specified order. The last 2 will be most friendly for a stock setup, I scrap/hit in a few places along broken arrow and I'm running a 2.5" lift and 33's. Another thing to consider is both Soldier's Pass and Broken Arrow are frequently congested with paid tours such as Pink Jeep Tours etc. I personally do not mind backing up a few times on the tight trails to let them pass, but some might. Below are pictures from Broken Arrow, including the famed "the steps" obstacle, as well as some pictures of Greasy Spoon trail, which is quickly becoming a favorite of mine.