I have the 2door long spider web shade and I was impressed with it when it was on my jeep. Right now I have a trek top nx on, mainly because of the swing in weather, but the spiderwebshade was on for about 2 weeks and I didn't have any issues. You can definitely tell the difference when it's on vs nothing. The long version I have comes all the way back to behind the rear seat head rests to give the passengers in the rear coverage on their necks. They also sell side windows to complete a cage with the long version. It will be going back on once we get through our weather swings. The trek top nx is nice because I can zip off both the side and rear windows and I am left with a bestop bikini top that has a sun rider feature.