I'll bandwagon here, I like the original look.
However, I'm running these and I'll tell you that you might as well not be running a fender when it comes to splash, if you run these off-road with out doors you will be covered in it and the rig is going to need some interior love, personal experience. I'm not sure these are even street legal in some places but I have never had a problem.
What I do like is that they are a relatively cheap solution, I think the look pretty damn good but I went from the stock plastic black fenders to them. They are also pretty tough so you can beat on em and the wheel well really opens up if you are trying to fit some bigger tires or something.