It's a head tick. There is a recall for it to 100k miles I believe.
Not normal but extremely common. Go to the dealer let them screw up your motor a few times and maybe you'll get out of it ok.
Good luck
Overlander, can you shed some light on that recall? I googled it and find a bunch of other shit but nothing engine related. I also looked it up by vin and it says there are recalled for my vin. I have a 2012 but I'm not sure of manufacturing date, I will need to look when I get off work.
Sorry if I hijacked the thread